The wages of stone-pelting

Time to get real about the business of Kashmiri protesters.

In February this year, this blog had spoken about the challenge posed by evolving tactics of stone-pelting in Kashmir to the security forces.

The most critical  aspect of this response is the speed at which the security forces adapt to changing tactics of the protesters. That is the key from preventing this stone-pelting business to turn into a scourge and dominate the narrative in the local media.[link]

Samar Halarnkar, whom no one can ever allege of being biased against the Kashmiri separatists, has a piece on Kashmir in the Hindustan Times. The money-quote — about the stone-pelters — from his piece is here:

Do they do what they do because they believe or does, as the police often allege, money play a part?

“We earned Rs 200 to Rs 300 as daily wage labourers,” says one of a group of masked young stone throwers. “Now we get between Rs 1,000 to Rs 1,500.” Who pays them?  “The separatists,” one offers. In a quiet, two-room home with open drains outside, 20-year-old street icon, Owais Ahmed ‘Mandela’, freely admits to receiving money. Where does it come from? He shrugs.[Hindustan Times]

Of course, it is not some new earth-shattering discovery that money plays the most important part in this business of stone-pelting in Kashmir. And it was noted by this blog six months ago as well:

Unlike the usual incidents of stone-pelting which are an expression of spontaneous outburst by the protesters, there is substantive evidence to prove that the latest rounds of stone-pelting in Kashmir valley are a well organised racket, a lucrative business being run at the behest of Pakistan and Pakistan-backed separatists.[link]

It is also partly a failure of the Indian government to highlight the realities of these so-called Kashmiri freedom-fighters that has allowed the separatists to portray themselves as victims of the Indian state, whereas they are the real perpetrators of organised violence against the average Kashmiri and the Indian state. Natwar Singh has rightly pointed out:

A word about the media. It is perhaps the most powerful instrumentality available. It can alter perception, provide hope, remove hopelessness. On February 27, 1950 (long before TV arrived), Jawaharlal Nehru, in a letter to the chief ministers, wrote: “I would suggest to you especially to keep in touch with editors of newspapers in your state. It is always a good thing to send for them and have informal off-the-record talks with them. Give them such real news as you possess.”[Business Standard]

A government that professes to uphold the legacy of Nehru could do no better than act on his words. And get the truth out on Kashmir. Fast.


Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.

, , , , , , , ,

5 Responses to The wages of stone-pelting

  1. gbz September 22, 2010 at 9:40 am #

    On the same lines, an absolute absolute must read open letter from Gov.Jagmohan to rajiv gandhi from april 1990. What has changed? nothing.

    “You once said, ‘I do not read history; I make history’. Apparently, you do not know that those who happen to make history without reading it, usually make bad history.”

  2. gbz September 22, 2010 at 9:55 am #

    sorry to spam, but this is even better (same source):

    “… Talking of the Irish crisis, British Prime Minister Disraeli had said: “It is potatoes one day and Pope the next”. Similar is the present position in Kashmir. Yesterday, it was Maqbool Bhat; today it is Satanic Verses; Tomorrow it will be repression day and the day after it will be something else. The Chief Minister stands isolated. He has already fallen-politically as well as administratively; perhaps, only constitutional rites remain to be performed. His clutches are too soiled and rickety to support him. Personal aberrations have also eroded his public standing. The situation calls for effective intervention. Today may be timely, tomorrow may be too

  3. stoney September 23, 2010 at 10:44 am #

    Our Intel is preoccupied trying to nail the BJP and target them as saffron terrorists rather than countermeasures in J&K. Today a BBC correspondent interviewed a Kashmiri girl whose father was killed in Police firing. She said that after a cup of tea the separatists came and told her father that if he was a “True Muslim” he would join the stone throwing crowd. They coerced him into joining the rally. What was our intel services doing? Trying to nail Modi for eliminating a hardcore criminal, or saving the skin of Sajjan, or proving that terror has a colour viz – saffron? Why arent the democratically elected leaders out on the streets rather tghan the separatists. Why isnt the Administration out on the streets rather than the ISI?


  1. Tweets that mention Pragmatic Euphony » The wages of stone-pelting -- - September 19, 2010

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by N.James, Raksha Mantri and Sonali Ranade, Sangh Parivaar. Sangh Parivaar said: The wages of stone-pelting: Time to get real about the business of Kashmiri protesters. In February this year, thi… [...]

  2. Pragmatic Euphony » Actions have consequences - February 26, 2012

    [...] the gang to throw stones at policemen, indulging in arson or destroying public property. The petty cash paid by Pakistan-backed separatists for taking part in those organised protests were never going to compensate you for the losses you [...]

Leave a Reply