Following K Subrahmanyam’s advice

P Chidambaram must now walk the talk, and execute K Subrahmanyam’s vision of creating a ministry of internal security.

Although the complete text of 22nd Intelligence Bureau Centenary Endowment Lecture on A New Architecture of India’s Security by P Chidambaram should be mandatory reading for all students of internal (and national) security, here is an extract from the lecture — the portion dealing with the restructuring of the Union Home Ministry.

That leaves the question of the structure of the Ministry of Home Affairs itself.  MHA now handles a wide portfolio of subjects ranging from ‘freedom fighters’ to ‘forensic science’.  Is this a functional arrangement to deal with the grave challenges to internal security that we face and that we will face from many more years?  I am afraid not.  It is true that the words ‘Ministry of Home Affairs’ have an authoritative ring, but the MHA now performs a number of functions that have no direct relation to internal security.  For example, it has a division dealing with freedom fighters but it does not have even a desk for dealing exclusively with forensic science.  There are other divisions or desks that deal with Centre-State Relations, State Legislation, Human Rights, Union Territories, Disaster Management, Census etc.  These are undoubtedly important functions and deserve close attention.  However, internal security is an equally, if not more, important function that deserves the highest attention.  In my view, given the imperatives and the challenges of the times, a division of the current functions of the Ministry of Home Affairs is unavoidable.  Subjects not directly related to internal security should be dealt with by a separate Ministry or should be brought under a separate Department in the MHA and dealt with by a Minister, more or less independently, without referring every issue to the Home Minister.  The Home Minister should devote the whole of his/her time and energy to matters relating to security.[PIB]

This is in keeping with the prescription suggested by the doyen of Indian strategic experts, K Subrahmanyam — a one-man defence university, in the words of BG Verghese — in January this year.

What’s paramount is the setting up of a ministry — under the charge of a Cabinet Minister — that is dedicated to internal security. Internal security should not be part of the Home Ministry’s responsibilities. Just as we have a ministry for external security, which is the Ministry of Defence, India needs a Ministry for Internal Security. …In my view, it would be good to have a wholly dedicated Ministry for Internal Security. …What I suggest is that a Cabinet Minister must devote full attention to internal security. Something analogous to the US Department of Homeland Security.[BS]

Any government or minister that listens to K Subrahmanyam couldn’t be doing much wrong. Only if the government would now implement the plan with steadfast purpose, firm determination and unwavering commitment.



Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.

, , , , , , , ,

13 Responses to Following K Subrahmanyam’s advice

  1. NotReallyAnonymous December 24, 2009 at 3:20 am #

    It is not just internal security thats needs to be branched out, I see a lot of potential for devolving some of the other MHA tasks to local governments.

  2. ji December 24, 2009 at 8:29 pm #

    Does anyone in the military – Sepoy to S/ General read what KS or say Khushwant Singh has to say about the state of ‘ affairs’

  3. capillus272 chaz bono before and after August 2, 2014 at 12:08 am #

    Hair is linked to our self-worth and our personality.
    They use a multi-therapeutic approach, trying to win the
    war on hair loss by using every possible angle. FUE leaves only small,
    circular scars that heal without the need for sutures.

  4. igrow induction lighting cannabis August 15, 2014 at 10:44 am #

    Even frequent blow-drying at extreme heat or brushing obsessively
    can cause your hair to become extremely fragile causing it to break
    and fall out. Consult with a veterinarian for the proper dosage based on the individual pig’s weight.
    Your hair protected the top of the head from the elements.

  5. Ft North Best Fort Lauderdale Plumbers August 19, 2014 at 10:18 am #

    If you want to take care of your property, the number one thing
    that you should do is to know your budget. Reusing gray water can be
    a good move for you and the environment, if it is done correctly and responsibly.
    Old electrical wiring in a house built 30 or more years ago
    could have failing insulation and be a fire waiting to happen.

  6. facial plastic surgery ucla August 20, 2014 at 4:24 pm #

    To keep you in the most comfortable and peaceful state of mind
    possible, Dr. Laser procedures are also used to
    diminish the emergence of age spots and wrinkles and also to resurface your skin. By using a radio frequency face lift, many
    men and women can prolong the need for a full-fledged face lift later on in life.

  7. howard schwartz cpa esq boca raton florida August 27, 2014 at 10:50 am #

    They will create profit and loss statements from your old
    bank statements. When making these accounts please make
    sure that you:. Variety of professionalism that are shown by a los
    angeles accountant will end up as an amazing asset in selecting a
    good accountant to fill your family needs.

  8. miami movers 123 August 28, 2014 at 7:19 pm #

    Hence, considering the basic factors in mind, one can certainly be rest assured about the comfortable and smoother relocation. This article has been flagged as spam, if you
    think this is an error please contact us. • Must know
    how to assess injury risks that comes with hazardous manual handling.

  9. yoga For hair growth for women September 5, 2014 at 7:43 am #

    Quite a few treatment centers impose as per the time required each meeting.
    However, it comes with a relatively steep price tag of $500 or more.

    There are a number of lasers used to remove locks like Ruby aesthetic laser, Alexandrite laser, Pulsed diode array, Aragon aesthetic
    laser as well as Nd:YAG.

  10. celebrity dress up justin bieber stardoll September 20, 2014 at 7:19 am #

    Fashion is something which improves your lifestyle in most amazing manner and it is
    all about making simplest dresses more exclusive with styling.
    While most dresses are basic silk, satin, or tulle, some are nestled underneath an overlay of cotton lace to
    create a more textured appearance. Full body lace is finest worn with a smooth
    tank top.

  11. Female Escort Agency Bangalore November 23, 2014 at 9:24 pm #

    Tall escort service, and simply smart escorts in Bangalore can forever be retrieve at your service! We have the most amazing collection of beautiful Escorts available for incall and outcall service. And not only they are picturesque and friendly ? they are broad minded and eager to give their clients full pleasure.


  1. Pragmatic Euphony » Accountability from the Home ministry - February 3, 2010

    [...] aftermath of the ghastly terror attack on Mumbai in November 2008. He has spoken at length about restructuring the internal security mechanism in the country, undertaken some bold initiatives on countering the Maoists and enunciated the [...]

  2. Peace process, redux | The Filter Coffee - June 17, 2010

    [...] hopes to secure India, then its efforts are best directed towards strengthening the country’s internal security, while ensuring a capacity to challenge terror infrastructure where it [...]

Leave a Reply